By SANDRA LORD – Caribbean

When I attended performing arts school in New York, each semester I found myself one of few black students in the classroom. The rest of the students were primarily Caucasian, many from Europe and Canada.
I thought nothing much of it until one day a fellow classmate from Holland asked me if I knew how she could get her Green Card. I was taken off guard. The fact is, until that moment, it had never dawned on me that any of my fellow classmates was in the U.S. illegally – after all, they were um…white.
It turned out that several of them were here illegally, including those from CANADA.
I’ve never stopped thinking about that for like many Americans, I had subconsciously been brainwashed to believe that illegal immigrants were brown, black and yellow.
So, you would understand why, whenever the issue of immigration comes up, as with the new immigration law in Arizona, it makes me stomping mad, for without fail, illegals are generally portrayed as people of color – specifically Latin Americans.
For the bigots under the guise of “I love my country and want to protect it” like that buffoon, Lou Snobbs, I mean, Dobbs, white illegal immigrants never seem to make it into the equation when the issue of illegal immigration comes up.
Also, I never hear people talking much about securing the Canadian border, where a multitude of Canadians pass through and never go back.
Yes, that includes some of our celebrities. Hollywood is full of Canadians who made it big here – Jim Carrey, Michael J. Fox, Nicolette Sheridan, Pamela Anderson, William Shatner, Neve Campbell, Avril Lavigne, Howie Mandel, Dan Akroyd, Kim Cattrall, Martin Short, Paul Shaffer, Nelly Furtado, , Hayden Christensen, Mike Myers, Keanu Reeves, Kiefer Sutherland, Sandra Oh, Matthew Perry, Eric McCormack, Alex Trebeck, etc., etc.
But I wonder how many of them were actually here legally at the time they got their big break. I wonder how many had a Green Card, work permit or the backing of a television or film studio or record company that allowed them to pursue or gain employment in the United States when they sauntered over the Canadian border to pursue their dreams, aye? I have no beef with the Canadians at all, but I just wonder if anyone bothered to ask. I don’t think so!
One of the key provisions of the new Arizona immigration law “requires police officers to ‘make a reasonable attempt’ to determine the immigration status of a person if there is a “reasonable suspicion” that he or she is an illegal immigrant.” What would constitute a “reasonable suspicion?” Pray tell. Oh wait. It continues. “Race, color or national origin may not be the only things considered in implementation.” That’s the joke of the year.
Based on who is typically viewed as “illegal,” in my opinion the Arizona bill is inherently racist, not to mention unconstitutional.
The new bill endorses racial profiling and gives racist cops full authority to indulge in overt racist practices. For, if you look anything even remotely like some policeman’s perception of an illegal immigrant, to be blunt, non-white, you are at risk of being stopped at will and put through the indignity of producing documents showing that you’re in the good ole USA legally.
The thing is, there is no adjunct system in place that tells immigration-happy cops that you’ve already been hassled; say something like a stamp on your forehead or on your wrist (like the ones you get at the nightclubs) to show that you’ve already proven your status for that day or week or year. This annoyance can intrude into your life multiple times a day, 24/7, 365 days a year “whenever and where-ever an officer requests.” Talk about freedom of movement! It kinda smacks of the good old days of slavery whereby people of color had to carry their freedom papers, doesn’t it?
Maybe all immigrants who’ve been checked and passed the test the first time should just be given an electronic ankle or wrist bracelet that immediately signals “immigration approved” to avoid any further hassle.
Yes, we undoubtedly need sweeping immigration reform. And, ironically, I do understand the frustration of the state of Arizona, which has one of the highest rates of illegal immigration in the country, a state that has received little help from a federal government responsible for securing its borders. But Arizona has opened up a can of worms with the nature of this new bill.
Rounding up people because they look a certain way or are suspected of being in violation of immigration law or arbitrarily detaining them on the basis of skin color and accent is not a good idea and can only lead to a severe violation of people’s fundamental civil rights.
I seriously hope that this law is not introduced in California or other States.
I am not just expressing my opinion on this subject. I am voicing my displeasure from experience.
Several years ago, fellow guest blogger on this blog and friend, blonde, blue-eyed Melody Jackson gave me a ride home from one of my Hollywood Networking Breakfast events. When we got to my home, we sat in the car chatting for a moment. Up ahead, we noticed several police cars with as many policemen looking around. We didn’t think much of it, but as I got out of Melody’s car, my arms full with all my breakfast stuff, beautifully dressed in one of my famous tailored business suits, I was suddenly accosted by three policemen who wanted to know what I was doing in this Beverly Hills neighborhood.
Having heard horror stories about cops and blacks, I was naturally suspicious, but I calmly told them ‘I live here.’ No, they wanted proof that I did. In America? Yessirree!
I had not committed any crime, so I asked them why was I being stopped? Well, the expressions on their faces said they couldn’t believe I had the audacity to ask.
Melody’s expression was utter shock as in, “I can’t believe this is happening.”
The Amazon female policeman and the physically- challenged, Napoleonic-complexed male cop barked, “We are not letting you leave until you show us your ID.”
I was livid and the stench of their attitude did not help at all. Then they seemingly had a brainstorm! The third cop waddled over to Melody and asked for her ID. Brilliant move to save face and “cover their asses!” Melody complied. After seeing that and not knowing exactly what the law was in such circumstances, I finally had to drop all my stuff and show them my ID. [You gotta pick your battles, I guess.]
So, after they had gotten their kicks from their power trip that day, the pint-sized turd and his whale jumped into their car, and giving me the finger, roared away making monkey faces at me. My neighbors all had their jaws dropped. In fact, it was one of my neighbors who shouted to me “He flipped you the bird” – alerting me to the cop’s stubby erect middle finger, no doubt a vivid replica of his own other physical shortcomings.
Some members of my family have had incidents of being accosted by police demanding ID, guns drawn, simply for being in an affluent neighborhood, even though that’s where they lived, shopped and dined.
So, you will understand why, as an accented naturalized U.S. citizen of color, I am not keen on the “show your ID” laws such as that of Arizona. That now gives rogue cops an excuse, not to mention, carte blanche to hassle people of color, beautifully dressed or not, under the guise of “authenticating immigration status.”
America is known and marketed as the land of opportunity, so is it any wonder that most people want to come and seek a better life in this country? Heck, this country was built on immigrant labor and the majority of white Americans are descendants of immigrants.
So, if America had closed its borders generations ago, where would we be? And to take it further, most Americans are virtually immigrants in a land that is indigenously Indian. Many illegal immigrants have fought in the U.S. army for our freedom and the right to even rally against them in a self-righteous manner. Did you know that?
Then there are those anti-immigration activists who want children born to undocumented immigrants in the U.S. (so-called “anchor babies”) to assume the nationality of the parents – clearly Mexicans. There are some who go further and want the American born children to be deported with their illegal parents. So, to deprive children the recognition of their country of birth is constitutional? Silly me, I thought if you were BORN IN AMERICA, you were American and in that unique capacity you can even run for the highest office in the land – President.
And what is the beef with Mexicans anyway? Some of my friends argue that illegals are a burden to the healthcare, welfare and economic system; they take jobs away from hardworking Americans; the Arizona bill will result in “less crime,” “lower taxes,” “safer neighborhoods,” “shorter lines in the emergency rooms,” “smaller classrooms,” yada, yada, yada.
Most or all of that may be true, but let’s not put the entire burden on the backs of Mexicans. ALL illegal immigrants (Europeans and Canadians included) put a burden on the country’s resources.
From my observations, most Mexicans are a hardworking people doing work in which most Americans have no interest. They are an important part of life as we know it, with many industries depending on a cheap and undocumented workforce to survive — from our farms, restaurants and landscaping, to the care of our children, cleaning of our homes and offices, the construction of our streets and buildings etc. Even some of my African American friends, another minority, blame Latinos for their troubles. I don’t know one of them who would want to work these jobs.
At the end of the day, immigrants have the same hopes, dreams and aspirations as any American, to make life better for themselves and their families in this land of hope and opportunity.
So, to those who say we need to bring this country back to what it was, what exactly does that mean and how far back do you want to go? I daresay the native Indians would be happy to have their country back and the Mexicans would like to have their land with all the still Spanish-named towns and cities back.
I am not at all advocating illegal immigration, but I do believe that if sweeping exclusionary measures are put into place, and people are required to produce ID authenticating legal status, then it should be an all-inclusive, “equal opportunity roundup” – Europeans, Canadians, Latinos – the whole lot.
But most importantly, I do believe that an immediate viable solution is amnesty for illegals currently here, who have paid taxes and lived an exemplary life.
After that, I say, “America, secure ALL your borders.”
In the meantime, I don’t think I’ll be going to Arizona any time soon.
And by the way, the last time I checked, the term “illegal” was a crime, NOT a race.

If there was respect and love for people in our Universe what a wonderful world it would be.
Isn’t it the truth that we as Americans want people to like us, respect us, honor us and accept us as is but we as Americans have a big problem doing the same to others.
everything seems to be blamed on the immigrant. all of Americans problems are caused by the immigrant. i would like to know how many immigrants were handling our money on wall street.
Colotl should definitely stay and finish college. She is obviously very bright. But I would not give her a free ride. I would make sure she gives back to the community in exchange for leniency.
As Bill Cosby said on the Tonight Show RACISM IS A WASTE OF TIME.
VIVA AMERICA!
Arizona’s racial profiling bill is the new American Express. People of color just can’t leave home without their papers. It is amazing to me that if I am away on one of my sales trips and my wife who has brown skin and an accent forgets her ID at home, she can be arrested and detained until it can be verified that she is in this country legally, until I get back home. She has no family here. So unless you go through that kind of discrimination, as I, as a white man, have experienced with my wife, you don’t know what you are talking about. It’s a double standard and it’s a shame.
Do any of you know the number of police officers that have been killed and maimed by illegal immigrants in Arizona? There’s a huge criminal element in that state and the cops don’t know who’s who. Come on, SOMETHING had to be done. I wholeheartedly support AZ.
The federal government cannot continue to abdicate its duty to guard the borders and manage immigration. Both republican and democrat administrations have failed miserably in that regard and the current administration under Barak Obama doesn’t seem remotely interested in addressing far less taking care of the problem.
Heres where I agree with Jan Brewer who had to do what she had to do. Arizona has over HALF A MILLION illegal aliens. FAIR – the Federation for American Immigration Reform reports that illegal immigrants take $1.6 billion from Arizona’s education system, $694.8 million from health care services, $339.7 million in law enforcement and court costs, $85.5 million in welfare costs and $155.4 million in other general costs. What’s a state to do?
Here’s where I agree with you Sandra. The bill unfairly targets one group. There are many many illegal Europeans and Canadians in the U.S. I also agree with you to some extent that we need to properly secure our borders and to provide amnesty for those illegals that have been here for the last 10 years. However, I do not believe that those who have been given amnesty should ever become citizens and have the right to vote. They should just be given permanent status and just that.
There’s no easy answer because the genuine arguments against illegal immigration are unfortunately tempered by the troubling issue of racism.
I love this BLOG!
VAMOOSE back to Mexico Pablo, Jose, Javier, Juan, Edmondo, Maria, Paulina and all your little poquitos.
I like Latinos I just do not like the ones who come over here illegally and commit crimes. Not every Latino is bad.
I found it took a long time for Sarah Palin to jump on the bandwagon with Jan Brewer with the immigration bill. Sarah Sarh Sarah when is enough enough?
Oh Sarah Palin. The dumbest of the dumbest, but the smartest at fooling the American people. She finally joined the immigration debate and she can’t even see Mexico from her house. LOL. LYAO!!!
The govnor of Arizona is giving more fuel to all the racist cops who has racist agendas and excuses to do racial profiling.
If Michael J. Fox, Jim Carrey, Avril Lavigne, Howie Mandel, Nelly Furtado, Mike Myers, Keanu Reeves, Kiefer Sutherland, Sandra Oh, Matthew Perry, etc. did not jump the line we would have missed a lot. Let them all in.
I do not care about the color of skins, the law is the law. Everyone has to take the line and wait their turn.
Jan brewer you are a witch. karma IS a bi**h.
I say, send all of them back to where they crawled from.
The Arizona bill sounds good for some people until it knocks on their door.
There are many talented people of all race. America would not survive if not for the mix of people.
Give a dog a bone and they run with it, look at Jan Brewer, she is milking it for all its worht and she’s still running. Just remember what Jan Brewer has done when its election time b/c she will have the balls to run all the way to the next elections. Racist piglet.
its funny how we boast about America the great, freedom of speech, etc but when ever someone opens up their mouth and says something we do not want to hear we cry foul and fry them like refried beans.
We have seen it over and over again, all those old foggies who fought to keep blacks out of good schools and kept racism alive here in America have all died and left the land they were fighting for. The message, you do not go with anything. Let it go.
I hope Americans are smart enough to know that Jan Brewer is doing that for her to be re elected. Its all POLITICS at the Mexican’s expense.
No one ever really thought of how far Hitler would go when he started tagging Jews and prosecuting those that tried to help them. We must remember that when we start tagging one race.
Wow. Doesn’t look like more Mexicans will be coming here any time soon. Just wishful thinking!
Today one group is targeted. Tomorrow it will be another. When we’ve gone through all the races, they will come get the poor white trash. lol.
Hey girls, Sarah Palin has just joined the immigration debate. What an opportunistic bia*ch!
I’ve never liked Phil Jackson. I’m glad his true colors are showing.
The Lakers should watch Phil Jackson. He supports the Arizona bill. Phil just remember this. A lot of people of color are on your team and pay your salary, you are a sell out.
terrorism before racism. America prioritize your issues.
What riles me is her sense of entitlement. She sounds like she is doing America a favor by being here and getting good grades she feels like she should be allowed to stay. Whether or not she didn’t ask to be here and she has a great point average she’s here illegally. That’s the main thing.
Are you guys CRAZZZZZZYYY? Jessica what’s her name should be deported for being in this country illegally. What’s wrong with you people that encourage people to break the laws of this country? Do you think any American can go to Mexico and do what Jessica has done and STAY?
Jessica Colotl’s parents brought her to the U.S. illegally when she was a 10 year-old. She had no say in the matter. She’s smart and ambitious and the kind of immigrant America can benefit from. So, what purpose would it serve to deport her to a Mexico she doesn’t even know.
Brewer is brewing hate in Arizona. Her wicked witches brew is spilling over into other states.
Somebody else said here that we should focus on the terrorists and not the Mexicans. I WHOLEHEARTEDLY AGREE. I have never heard of a Mexican terrorist. The new face of terrorism is the blond, blue eyed type that assimilates into this country and whom we are giving a FREE pass. Racism is about to backfire on us big time in this country. Sadly we’ll probably only realize that when the next terror act occurs as our backs are turned escorting the Mexicans out.
This lady is single highhandedly killing all the progress that Reagan and Bush 1 & 2 did with Latinos in the past.
Let he with no sin cast the fist stone. People keep talking about illegals have broken the law. How many of you have lied on your taxes, made a left turn where you should not, bring stuff into the country that you should not, etc. We are all guilty of something or other just haven’t been caught. Since the law is the law. How many of us would be able to stand examination? Leave the damn Mexicans alone.
I sympathize with Jessica Colotl. She is being targeted also because she is smart. Jealous Americans are mad that she does not speak in stilted English like they expect most Mexicans to. Her GPA is 3.8. So you deport her, whose loss?
Americans can’t even read, write or speak English but the whine and complain about immigrants not speaking it.
These days many Americans are looking for jobs and will take EVEN $8 jobs. Believe me, when the Mexicans are deported there will be people lining up for those jobs. Guaranteed.
To Barbara M. if American students had Jessica Colotl’s GPA or better, they would be in college. Let’s not mix apples and oranges. She academically qualified to be in college, which obviously you and those who you know are not and that’s why you are griping. Get a better argument and while you’re at it get a life.
How about Jessica Colotl? I don’t care how bright she is. She should be deported. She’s here illegally and taking the rightful place of an American or legal immigrant in college.
Excellent article! i am just Tired of conservatives getting on their soap box and putting down everyone that doesn’t look like them.
whatever happened to the cultural melting pot that is supposed to be America.
Just watch. A ban on Black History Month will be next. It’s coming…
Arizona is on the right track. They should save a ton of money and preserve the integrity of the white race in the process.
I do not enjoy going into businesses and seeing signs in spanish, or when i call a company the messages starts in english than goes to spanish. That is very annoying to me. We are a one language country and that’s how it should stay. Everyone should learn to speak the language. It should not be the ohter way around to inconvenient the rest of us.
God Bless America. Every single color and race that continues to build this nation.
Finally a politician with guts and integrity. FINALLY a politician standing up for Americans and WHITE people in general! Just because we stand up for our rights we are labeled racists. Well, so be it. Thank you Jan Brewer. You have more support than you know.
Fear has driven this nation to commit horrific acts against people of different races, but I never realized how stupid, selfish and bigoted we are as a country until I started reading the debates on this immigration issue.
Arizona is now a police state.
Ethnic studies are inherently anti white and anti American. I’m glad Jan Brewer had the guts to do what so many liberals are afraid to do. My deep admiration goes to the little lady.
What goes around come around. Funny how history repeats itself. First “anglos” took land from the indians. and Now “latinos” are taking it back. see we will be the majority pretty soon. lol. he who laughs last wins. hahahahah
The KKK doesn’t need the white sheets anymore. The new Arizona laws give them freedom to openly hate, murder, rape and do all the sordid things for which they are known all in the name of preserving the so called white race. People are not going to sit down and take this shit. Just so you know.
a whole lotta hate toward ethnics coming out of arizona these days. the white washing of AZ has begun 1st the mexicans, then the ethnic studies. when all the color is gone from the nazi state, white trailer trash you’re next. wait a minute, but that’s the whole state. one lump of stinky garbage. aw
why do liberals hate America so much?
Sandra I know you stand for diversity and all that with changing images and the work you do but I gotta tell ya I’ll be the first to stand in line to round em up when the bill passes in California. you are here legally so what do you care. Enough of this s***t.
OMG I’m embarrassed to say I’m from ARizona now. These laws are so un-American.
Arizona is obviously the home of white supremacists, mostly toothless, right wing neo nazi, gun toting, incest loving trailer trash red necks – some disguised in suits some more obvious in cowboy boots and a sneer for immigrants. Here’s MY new anti-rabid a$$h**le law. All decent people should get a rabies shot when they see anyone that fit that profile. Amen.
conservatives cannot be THAT dumb…can they?
Brewer and Palin in 2012.
Enough already. People need to just stop with the arguments about this country being stolen from the Native Americans and Mexicans.. the US is the US. People should be charged with treason for speaking against this country. If you dont like it, move somewhere else.
All very true, but I don’t agree myself. I will stay the more traditional view. But I without doubt support your right to have your own point of view. Interesting topic.
America interferes with everyone’s human rights. Look in your own backyard and take care of the serious violation of human rights happening right under your nose. Land of the free my a**!
The beauty of America is its diversity. The white washing of America, i.e., removing all the color from it will only make it the most boring country in the world. Color ALWAYS adds pizzazz and makes a huge difference to everything.
Yes, a whole lotta scared white people in Arizona.
First, the US steals New Mexico, Arizona, and California from Mexico and didn’t even bother to change all the Spanish names of the streets, cities, towns and states. Then they put up a border and said it’s illegal to cross that border. And if you cross that border you will be illegal and it is a crime to be Mexican while in the US.
It is not the job of the educational system to teach people about their culture. It’s up to the parents and extended family. The ban on ethnic studies is long overdue because that is racist against white Americans.
Jan Brewer just wants to make Arizona a white state plain and simple. Sandra you are absolutely right, its the white washing of America, starting with Arizona.
I love your finesse that you put into your writing.
Governor Brewer has got my vote for President 2012. She’s a hero in my eyes and has more balls than most men. I’m excited to see what she’ll do next to continue to place Arizona as an example of great leadership.
To all the Black people who say to the Mexicans go back to Mexico.
When the Mexicans go back to Mexico who do you think the white people will be looking at to wash their toilet bowls, wipe the snot from their kids nose and toil the soil.
White people have been the oppressors for years and the Mexicans, African Americans, Jews and Japanese have the scars to prove it. Neither of these groups should be singling out the other for discrimination.
Jan Brewer please go back to your museum and stay there.
To Toto Republicans do not only hate Latinos they also hate themselves. They are filled with SELF LOATHING. That’s why they hate everyone.
Racial profiling is oppressive and immoral. Denying it doesn’t make it any more right.
To Yankee Doodle, what do you mean ‘If we had white studies every one would be screaming racism.” Where have you been gringo? You DO have white studies. Everything in the school books is about white studies even the inventions that your people stole from blacks, Indians and others and took for themselves. All the studies are about the great white hope you dope.
It would be a shame to do away with the ethnic studies classes. I am white and I took ethnic studies in college and they were some of the best classes that I took! I wish I could have had the opportunity to have learned what I from these classes in high school.They were educational and you got to see another point of view. White people where not roaming these lands first! Jan Brewer is getting out of hand and this new legislation is outrageous.
To hell with the gardeners, busboys, dishwashers, babysitters, etc. BUT I’ll miss the refried beans. heheh
I’m honestly ashamed to be a white person in Arizona right now. I want to apologize of all the hatred that white people are directing toward Mexicans and all the pain we have inflicted and continue to put on people of color.
Viva Arizona!!
Hitler would be so proud of Arizona. You go Jan!
Jan Brewer is right to sign this new measure against ethnic studies. Most of these ethnic studies classes secretly try to re-write history so that Whites are hated. If we had white studies every one would be screaming racism.
Thank you for this article Sandra. It’s getting to a point where being Latino or even looking like one is a crime.
REPUBLICANS HATE LATINOS.
Jan Brewer should be your Media Jerk instead of Kate Goselin. Maybe next time? In the meantime maybe they can be a duo and go on dancing with the stars as partners. LOL really loud. hehehe!
Governor Jan Brouhaha (thank you Bon Jovi Fan, it’s a great name for her) signed another measure yesterday that “prohibits classes that advocate ethnic solidarity, that are designed primarily for students of a particular race or that promote resentment toward a certain ethnic group.” How is it possible for someone to speak out of both sides of her mouth at the same time? Hey GI Jan, didn’t you just encourage that with your racist immigration bill?
Hooray for the brave ones that boycott Arizona. God bless the LA City Council and Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa for publicly challenging Arizona and showing their contempt for its racist immigration bill.